Skip to content

Digby's Hullabaloo Posts

He’s Losing It

Politico doesn’t go there but it’s obvious:

Top White House and administration officials have been promising businesses, consumers and fellow Republicans more “certainty” on trade in the coming days, eager to calm skittish markets and avoid the stock market plunge that accompanied the White House’s initial tariff roll-outs.

But they have one problem: Donald J. Trump.

Just days out from Trump’s April 2 announcement of global tariffs, which he has hailed as “Liberation Day,” even those closest to the president — from Vice President JD Vance to his chief of staff Susie Wiles and his own Cabinet officials — have privately indicated that they’re unsure exactly what the boss will do, according to three people who have spoken with them…

“No one knows what the fuck is going on,” said one White House ally close to Trump’s inner circle, granted anonymity to speak freely. “What are they going to tariff? Who are they gonna tariff and at what rates? Like, the very basic questions haven’t been answered yet.”

When are people going to admit that he’s losing it? (To the extent that he ever had it, that is.) He probably isn’t remembering what he said from one day to the next and isn’t sure what he’s supposed to do. He is hanging on by his fingernails.

His team is concerned because he’s not paying any attention to economic warning signs that are all around us. But it’s also “because the president continues to throw curveballs at businesses — and even his own team.” What does that say?

Case in point: Wednesday’s decision to slap the auto industry with 25 percent tariffs. While expected in some fashion in the near future, the announcement came together so last minute that the White House wasn’t fully prepared and had to delay afternoon programming as they sought to finalize the plan, according to two people familiar with the roll-out.

The White House also didn’t brief industry stakeholders in the U.S. or abroad beforehand — though a White House official argued that if they were “smart” they would have known it was coming, since Trump himself issued a public warning.

Then he’s saying that he might not do it after all, but who knows?

“I may give a lot of countries breaks,” Trump said. “We might be even nicer than that.”

On Wednesday, he reiterated that potential reprieve, predicting to reporters that people will be “pleasantly surprised” by the “somewhat conservative” tariffs.

Look at how people try to find excuses for this erratic behavior:

“I think it would be a mistake to think next week all of a sudden we’re going to get a bunch of clarity,” said Tom Graff, chief investment officer at financial advisory firm Facet. “I’m sure they’re trying to reset with financial markets and build some certainty, but I don’t think the president is going to have a personality transplant.”

“I think he wants to keep his options open,” Graff added.

Bullshit. There’s no point to any of it. I won’t even quote what the White House sycophants are saying. You can only imagine.

Tell me this isn’t a man struggling with dementia:

Part of the uncertainty stems from the president seeming to undermine his own team at times. After Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent and Trump economic adviser Kevin Hassett said in recent weeks that only about 10 or 15 countries — or the “dirty 15,” as Bessent put it — would face reciprocal tariffs, Trump said Wednesday that actually every country will be hit with a tariff…

Indeed, Trump has continued to shift the scope, targets and timeline of his tariffs at a whiplash-inducing pace. The duties he promised, pre-inauguration, to levy on Canada and Mexico his first day in office shifted to Feb. 1, then Feb. 4, then March 4, before being largely rolled back until April 2. There is little clarity about what parts of those tariffs — which could hit more than $1 trillion worth of trade — will go into effect next week.

The size of the so-called reciprocal tariffs, which the administration says it’s calculating for individual trading partners based on their treatment of U.S. imports, could also shift. Administration officials have indicated to foreign diplomats that those duties are meant to be a starting point for negotiations with other countries, meaning American companies may not know what if any tariffs will stick.

Trump also threatened to impose tariffs April 2 on various critical industries, including pharmaceuticals, semiconductors, copper and lumber, before indicating in recent days that those tariffs are likely to be delayed.

The “planning” is in total chaos. Any country that wants to avoid these inane tariffs has no idea if they’re coming or what they might be although Lutnick has said he’d try to give them a “heads up” if he can.

Apparently, the team is divided and each side is trying to influence the addled president although that probably won’t make any difference. Bessent, Wiles and Vance have all tried to get him to narrow the tariffs and make a final decision (despite surprising Wall St with their public support for whatever Trump does) but he doesn’t listen.

And then there are the true blues:

On the other hand, Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick and Navarro are said to be encouraging Trump’s long-standing tariff fixation.

The divisions have caused tensions. While Navarro is a genuine tariff believer, Lutnick — who has a close relationship with Trump and enjoys influence that others in the Cabinet do not, as of yet — is widely seen as supporting whatever Trump wants to ingratiate himself with the president, a dynamic that has infuriated others in the administration.

“He goes into the Oval and tells the president whatever he wants to hear,” said the first White House ally, who called Lutnick a “fucking nightmare” and argued he does so without consideration of the economic consequences.

Republicans are worried:

“If tariffs did have an inflationary impact — or an impact on interest rates that caused inflation and the economy moved toward a recession — that would be a very bad thing in my judgement,” Sen. John Kennedy (R-La.) told POLITICO, though he acknowledged a skilled rollout could work. “It would turn the Trump presidency from a four year term into a two year term, because we’d lose in the midterms.”

Ya think? The stubborn old man doesn’t hear any of that because he’s ignorant, has always believed his own hype and is losing his grip all at the same time:

The problem Trump’s own advisers and Hill Republicans face is that the president doesn’t share their alarm. He’s long believed that other countries are cheating America and that tariffs will usher in a new period of economic growth — economists’ warnings be damned. While many Hill Republicans have sought to justify his tariff obsession by chalking it up to a negotiating tactic, the reality is Trump really believes in the protectionist policies pushed by aides like Navarro, the longtime trade adviser whom Republicans almost universally distrust. The president also believes that his tariffs are popular with voters.

That’s because he’s not all there. They know it too, they just won’t admit it. He’s in his own world:

“The president isn’t looking at it like they are,” said one of the people close to Trump’s inner circle of the president’s advisers.“For [him], if the economy tanks, then fine, the economy tanks — because the president truly believes that it will rebound and the countries will give in because they can’t withstand the pressure from the U.S.”

As for political blowback, this person continued: “No. 1, the president is not running for reelection — so where this may have been a political concern in his first term, it’s not a political concern now. … And No. 2, we’re probably gonna lose the House in the midterms.”

Yes, eventually the economy will rebound. It always does in the long run. But as J.K. Galbraith famously said, “in the long run we’ll all be dead.”

I love this:

It’s unclear how candid Trump’s advisers have been to the president about their fears. One White House ally on the outside close to Trump’s team said even his most senior advisers abhor telling Trump what he doesn’t want to hear — but another argued that the president simply isn’t internalizing the warnings.

“I don’t think it’s like no one wants to tell Trump the bad, the hard news,” said one of the outside allies mentioned above. “I think people have tried to have a conversation with him, and he’s dead set on it. He’s a true believer.”

That’s because he’s not all there. It’s obvious in a million different ways. And they are all now in protective mode, far beyond anything we saw with Biden who was just showing normal elderly decline, nothing like this.

They say that people’s character traits often become more pronounced when dementia sets in. They can also become more stubborn, largely because they find themselves often confused and disoriented so they exert whatever power they have over others to reassure themselves that they’re still in control. And yes, in Trump’s case, he’s completely in old man YOLO mode, doing whatever he wants determined to prove that he’s always been right about everything. I hesitate to think what he’s going to do if and when reality blows up in his face.

When is the media going to start looking at this seriously?

Every Day This Gets Harder

But also for the Gangster-in-Chief

And you, to whom adversity has dealt the final blow
With smiling bastards lying to you everywhere you go
Turn to, and put out all your strength of arm and heart and brain
And like the Mary Ellen Carter, rise again

— “The Mary Ellen Carter,” by Stan Rogers, 1979

Friends ask me how I am, and my stock reply is now “Managing my stress.” My mother, 93, tells me she and her friends are all wondering whether their Social Security checks will arrive in April. But then that’s just what a “fraudster” would say, according to Donald Trump’s billionaire Commerce Secretary, Howard Lutnick, speaking from whatever planet that bastard lives on. My mother and her friends know all about his comments.

A friends laments that too many in the progressive sphere seem to think clicktivism is enough. Another looks at the descent of the U.S. into will-to-power lawlessness and says there’s nothing you can do. But that’s not true.

Read this carefully:

There is a lesson in there: Stand up to Trump and he backs down. He has a loud bark and a glass jaw.

In case you need reminding what Carney did:

So attend those protests, the big and the small. Contact your representatives, even the MAGA ones. Write letters to the editor. Make phone calls for Susan Crawford in Wisconsin (the election is Tuesday). Even if the checks keep coming, I promise you that those reliably voting seniors on Social Security won’t forget the Trump-inspired stress and worry they feel over whether they will be able to pay their bills or, you know, eat.

The smiling, lying bastards only win if you give up first.

(h/t ER)

* * * * *

Have you fought the coup today?

National Day of Action, Saturday, April 5
Choose Democracy
Indivisible: A Guide to Democracy on the Brink
You Have Power
Chop Wood, Carry Water
Thirty lonely but beautiful actions
Attending a Protest Surveillance Self-Defense

So Much Mayhem, So Little Time

Chaos fascism

“You don’t have the cards.”

The good citizens of Gotham City elected the Joker as mayor. He appointed his friends to high positions in government. Batman is MIA. Things have gone about as you’d expect.

You’ve noticed? So has Michael Tomasky. Some headlines:

Trump Takes Government Secrecy Seriously. But Only When It Suits Him.

10,000 Federal Health Workers to Be Laid Off

Federal officials are preparing for agencies to cut between 8 and 50 percent of their employees

Trump-as-Joker would fire the police too, but why bother with AG Pam Bondi (as Harley Quinn) deciding which Trump enemies to prosecute and which Trump crimes to ignore? (All of them.) Besides, he needs police as enforcers. There’s little chance that Senator John Thune and Representative Mike Johnson will launch CapitolHill investigations into anything Trump.

“That’s a lot of mayhem, and it barely scratches the surface,” Tomasky explains:

Across human history, fascism has been imposed upon democracy mostly in one of two ways. First, by brute force—a military coup, that sort of thing. Second, a bit more stealthily, and legally—through legislation, executive decrees, and court decisions that hand more power to the leader.

Donald Trump is inventing a new way. Call it chaos fascism. Destroy the institutions of democracy until they’re so disfigured or dysfunctional that a majority no longer cares about them.

But they’ll care about this. Musk-Trump is degrading the Social Security system while propagandizing against it “with absurd and false claims about 140-year-olds cashing checks.” DOGE claims after being embarrassed by that that it can replace SSA’s archaic-but-functional COBOL software that DOGE coders don’t understand with Java in a matter of months. Experts say years. DOGE says trust A.I.

Then wreck the agency so that its service becomes crap. Let public anger at it build. And in time, they can just dismantle it and privatize the greatest social insurance system ever devised by this government and put people’s financial fate in the hands of rich cronies. If that’s not chaos fascism, I don’t know what is.

Then there is DHS Secretary Kristi Noem, shooter of dogs, sans jackboots, sans black uniform, looking into the camera and warning the world that if you come to the U.S. and transgress the unwritten law, well, its a Salvadoran hellhole for you.

For now it is left to the courts to attempt to put the brakes on Joker’s plans for mayhem. He’s already defying them, but hasn’t yet seen his SCOTUS buddies rule on his most blatant actions. For now, the country is whistling past the constituional crisis. Defying SCOTUS could backfire, Politico suggests, but may get something Republicans can regret at their leisure:

Trump is likely to get some of what he wants from the Supreme Court when all is said and done — maybe even a lot of it. But it is always useful to remember that when a president manages to devise new and more powerful tools for himself — whether legal or political in nature — he leaves them for his successors too. And there is no telling what will happen and how those tools will be used over the long haul.

That assumes there is a long haul.

With Batman MIA and the courts with no army, stopping the Joker’s chaos fascism may take Americans in the streets by the millions. Saturday, April 5 is your big chance!

* * * * *

Have you fought the coup today?

National Day of Action, Saturday, April 5
Choose Democracy
Indivisible: A Guide to Democracy on the Brink
You Have Power
Chop Wood, Carry Water
Thirty lonely but beautiful actions

Friday Night Soother

Otter escapees!

Two river otters, Louie and Ophelia, weaseled their way out of their Wisconsin zoo enclosure last week during a winter storm, appearing on security camera footage cavorting across the snow, as the search continued Tuesday.

The NEW Zoo & Adventure Park said the two North American river otters escaped through a small hole that they enlarged in a buried fence, and their flight was quickly noticed by zookeepers on their morning rounds.

But Louie and Ophelia don’t appear to have gone far, their tracks showed them exploring nearby bodies of water and returning to the zoo’s perimeter now and again, the zoo said in a news release.

Footage released by the zoo shows an otter leaving the stoop of a building and launching itself into a belly slide on the snow, its forepaws snapping to its side, nose leading the way and back legs thrusting for an extra boost.

It’s the undeniable “bounce, bounce, sliiiiide” of the otter, the zoo said in a Facebook post, and creates one of the more recognizable mammal tracks.

Louie and Ophelia are expected to stay close because otters are territorial creatures, the zoo said, adding their species are native to the area and capable of surviving, with the local ponds and streams offering food and shelter.

Lol. Now they’re getting help. It’s a conspiracy!

“Raccoons have, unfortunately, impeded some of our efforts, even setting off one trap not

long before an otter arrived and tried to enter it,” the zoo said on social media.

Officials said they are now attempting to use “raccoon-proof” traps to ensnare the fugitive otters.

Godspeed my friends.

This Greenland Thing Is Happening

Trump said, “the United States will go as far as we have to go to own Greenland” the other day. Today he reiterated his demand saying, “we have to have it.”

He’s going to take it, one way or the other.

Vance is in Greenland making that clear:

REPORTER: The president said today, ‘We have to have Greenland.’ By being here today, are you also conveying that message?

JD VANCE: We can’t just ignore the president’s desires … this island is not safe.

JD Vance rails against Denmark from Greenland — “Our message to Denmark is very simple: You have not done a good job by the people in Greenland.”

JD Vance: “The president has said clearly he doesn’t think that military force is going to be necessary, but he absolutely believes that Greenland is an important part of the security not just of the US but of the world and of course the people of Greenland too … this has to happen.”

But hey, if that’s what it takes. The Danes and the Greenlanders just have to let us seize the country and that’ll be the end of it, amirite? They need to do what we tell them or …

None of this makes sense. If there is a strategic security issue, they could have worked it out through diplomacy. Denmark is a NATO ally and if Russia or China stages an incursion of Greenland, the US and all the Europeans are required to defend it already. If they want to put more troops there, I’m sure that could have been easily worked out.

But that assumes this is really about security. Yes, that may be a legitimate concern but it’s really just the excuse for Trump to seize a territory and make it part of the United States.

“You take a look at a map. I’m a real estate developer. I look at a corner, I say, ‘I’ve got to get that store for the building that I’m building,’ etc. It’s not that different,” Trump said. “I love maps. And I always said: ‘Look at the size of this. It’s massive. That should be part of the United States.'”

In 2019, he told reporters about a possible purchase, “Essentially, it’s a large real estate deal. A lot of things can be done.”

That’s what he wants. Remember, this is the man who unilaterally changed the name of the Gulf of Mexico to the Gulf of America.

By the way, yes, the rare earth minerals are a draw as well but they are actually not that rare. The idea that this is all about some great resource grab is overblown. It’s about Trump’s ego. And as I have said before, I think it may well work. They are willing to take the chance that Europe won’t fight it and if it finally blows up the Atlantic alliance, all the better. Both Trump and JD have made it quite clear that they consider the NATO countries to be irrelevant at best and enemies at worst.

QOTD: You Know Who

This one’s a doozy.

What is there to say?

Election Interference

Elon’s writing checks again:

Elon Musk said he’ll campaign in Wisconsin on Sunday, capping his unprecedented investment in the state’s supreme court race. It started with ad buys from his Building America’s Future PAC, continued with direct mail to Republicans from his America PAC, and accelerated with cash offers to voters who signed a petition to reject “activist judges who impose their own views” on citizens.

“I will also personally hand over two checks for a million dollars each in appreciation for you taking the time to vote,” Musk wrote on X, previewing his Sunday night appearance. It would be open, he said, to Wisconsinites who prove that they’ve voted in the race between Democratic Party-backed candidate Susan Crawford and GOP-backed Brad Schimel. Ben Wikler, the chairman of the Wisconsin Democratic Party, said that by offering $100 to voters who signed America PAC’s petition, and awarding $1 million prizes to a random supporters, Musk was “committ[ing] a blatant felony.”

He’s since changed his strategy now that he knows it’s illegal. He’ll be giving away the millions as part of a “sweepstakes” for those who sign a petition as he did in Pennsylvania last November.

But it’s pretty clear that nothing will be done about it. The big question is whether it will make a difference. They clearly believe that it did in Pennsylvania. Here’s little X spilling the beans:

Elon Musk’s son tells Tucker Carlson that Trump will win and the people “will never know”
byu/ControlCAD inmusked

Musk thinks this Wisconsin Supreme Court election is important because the future gerrymandering of the state is at stake and I suspect he and Trump also want to win this one with Musk’s participation to show that if he gets involved with his billions the other side has no chance. They are mostly aiming this at Republicans who might think of crossing Trump.

I don’t know that his money can buy it but there’s a reasonably good chance that the Republican Nazi running for the seat will win. It’s a very polarized state. And that will strengthen their hand for the upcoming battles in Congress and probably the courts. Every win makes them stronger and people who are just handing them to them because it’s the path of least resistance are nothing but collaborators.

I know I don’t have to tell any of my readers how important this is. Let’s just hope that more Democrats are motivated to come out that Republicans and that Musk’s money isn’t enough to make a difference.

Don’t Raise Prices Or Else

Trump is telling giant corporations that they aren’t allowed to raise prices from his tariffs. And apparently they are quaking in their boots, scared and trembling worrying about what the Great Orange Conqueror will do to them if they don’t do exactly what he wants:

When President Trump convened CEOs of some of the country’s top automakers for a call earlier this month, he issued a warning: They better not raise car prices because of tariffs.

Trump told the executives that the White House would look unfavorably on such a move, leaving some of them rattled and worried they would face punishment if they increased prices, people with knowledge of the call said. 

Instead, Trump said, they should be grateful for his elimination of what he called former President Joe Biden’s electric-vehicle mandate, which involved subsidies and emissions requirements to encourage electric-car production. He made a lengthy pitch for how they would actually benefit from tariffs, two people on the call said, adding that he was bringing manufacturing back to the U.S. and was better for their industry than previous presidents. 

The tariffs would be “great,” Trump said, according to one of the people.

On Wednesday, Trump announced a 25% tariff on all imported vehicles and parts starting April 2, a move almost certain to force American carmakers to raise prices on customers.   Most automakers depend on parts and materials from other countries to make cars, including vehicles assembled in the U.S. 

“You’re going to see prices going down, but going to go down specifically because they’re going to buy what we’re doing, incentivizing companies to—and even countries—companies to come into America,” he said at the event. 

All the brand new plants will be here by magic in a matter of weeks and all the laid off and fired scientists and engineers will be factory workers happily earning minimum wage! It’s the American Dream!

I’m not sure what the car company executives are afraid Trump is going to do to them but I’m sure it’s much worse than anything their shareholders would do if they lose money and their stock crashes. Dear Leader Uber Alles.

Trump And McKinley

Aaron Rupar’s great newsletter Public Notice features a great interview today by Thor Benson with historian Eric Rauchway discussing William McKinley and Trump’s ignorant obsession with tariffs. I highly recommend reading the whole thing. This sums up Trump’s idiocy on the subject:

“He wants the society of the 1950s with the policies of the 1890s. But you literally don’t get the society of the 1950s without a comprehensive rejection of the policies of the 1890s, even by Republicans.”

A short excerpt of the history lesson.

Thor Benson

Trump loves to talk about the late 1800s and early 1900s, how we paid for everything with tariffs instead of income taxes, and how great that period was. But I’m familiar with that era and know he’s full of it. There was massive income inequality and basically no social safety net. What’s he getting wrong about how average Americans lived during that time?

Eric Rauchway

You’d have to ask the average American who kept voting for socialists and populists and progressives. [laughs] They clearly wanted some kind of change.

That was the great era of unionization. It was the era of broad social protests. Many of the protesters thought tariffs were the cause of their misery.

A tariff is a regressive tax. It hurts people more the less money they have. The most progressive thing progressives wanted to do back then was have an income tax.

There had been an income tax during the Civil War, during the Lincoln administration, and then there was another one in the 1890s, but the Supreme Court said it was unconstitutional. One of the big things progressives wanted to do was bring that back, and ultimately they did with the 16th Amendment in 1913. That allowed the federal government to fund itself with income taxes rather than tariffs. That relieved a lot of people’s sense of unfairness toward the federal government.

The other problem with tariffs, people would say at the time, is that a tariff is the mother of trusts. The current president does not give evidence of understanding the difference between a tariff for revenue and a tariff for protection.

If you set a tariff at three percent, you collect three percent on all of your imports. That’s great. If you set a tariff at 300 percent, then nobody buys imports, so there’s no revenue collection. The president seems to believe he can impose prohibitively high tariffs and collect revenue, which you can’t do.

Thor Benson

But he says McKinley was the best.

Eric Rauchway

The president keeps saying he admires McKinley because of his high tariffs, but there are a couple things people these days like him seem to not understand very well.

One is that the McKinley tariff actually came before the McKinley presidency. The McKinley tariff is a law of 1890, and it’s called that because he was then the chair of the House Ways and Means Committee and a sponsor of the bill. McKinley didn’t get elected president until 1896. The McKinley tariff of 1890 was a prohibitively high protective tariff on many, many things.

Here’s the theory of protective tariffs: Let’s say, for example, we’re talking about hats, and the British make hats way better than Americans do. The American consumer, given the choice in an open market, will buy the British hat. American hatmakers suffer. You put a protective tariff on British hats to make it prohibitively expensive to buy a British hat, so people don’t buy British hats.

The federal government gets no money because there are no transactions on British hats. What there is, though, is room for American hatmakers to raise prices on their hats to just under the prohibitively high British price. They can now profit, because people will buy their hats at higher prices. Then, theoretically, they’re supposed to plow that money into research and development, so you are protecting, and therefore promoting, the American hat industry.

But what the United States actually did in the McKinley era is afford “protection” to companies that didn’t need it, like steel, where the United States was already highly competitive. All it allowed companies to do is have artificial room to raise their prices and increase profits. It gave an advantage to these firms to get bigger and bigger.

They were able to buy out the firms that supplied them with raw materials. They vertically integrated and became trusts. Tariffs aid monopolies. They’re to the advantage of people who own capital, who own factories, who employ factory workers. They’re intended to be pro-capital, and they are. That’s what gave rise to the great antitrust movement and the populist movement and ultimately the progressive movement.

There’s much more and it’s all fascinating.

We know Trump’s an idiot. But what excuses the people around him going along with it? Has it not occurred to them to read a book if they are unfamiliar with this history? I guess not. One of the problems with the ultra-rich finance moguls is that they all think they’re geniuses and don’t have anything to learn.

I also think we can’t underestimate the cult psychology at work. It’s clear to me that Trump’s ability to escape from all accountability, his ability to persuade massive numbers of people to believe his lies, his unlikely political comeback after J6 and now forcing powerful institutions like Universities and law firms to kow tow has made otherwise intelligent people to believe that he really does have godlike abilities. They know he’s stupid but somehow it doesn’t matter. he gets what he wants anyway. They’re just going along for the ride now, putting their fates and the fate of the world in his hands. These guys think he has the power to defy logic, reason and all the normal laws of economics.

It’s pre-modern. It’s insane.

The Time For Choosing Is Upon Us

Scene from “A French Village”

When Donald Trump won the election last November I think those of us who are mercifully immune to the lure of the MAGA cult knew that this second term was going to be bad. If you were following the campaign closely (many people were not) you knew about Project 2025 and you knew that Trump was inexplicably attached at the hip to the weird multi-billionaire Elon Musk. You also knew that he was fixated on starting a tariff war with America’s biggest trading partners and was irrevocably hostile to our long standing allies around the world. But I don’t think any of us could have predicted the exact confluence of atrocities being committed at warp speed from every direction. Shock and awe doesn’t adequately describe it. It is a cataclysmic political earthquake.

The full list of outrages is too long to list here and I assume that most informed readers know about most of them. But the general outline includes such abominations as masked government thugs abducting people off the street and disappearing them into a secret detention system, people being deported to a foreign gulag with no due process, curtailing cancer and Alzheimer’s research for no reason, shutting down dozens of vital government services, threatening social security and health care for millions of vulnerable citizens, targeting veterans, destroying foreign aid in ways that will literally result in the deaths of millions of people, using the Department of Justice to wreak revenge on the president’s enemies and much, much more. It is overwhelming, which is exactly how they planned it in Project 2025. The reality is much worse than the abstract planning document foretold.

And yet, most of us are still living our lives in more or less normal fashion. Yes, many immigrants, even those in the country legally are now living in a state of abject terror. And vast numbers of workers have abruptly lost their jobs with many more to come. But the vast majority of Americans are still going to work, taking the kids to school, hanging out with their friends, pursuing their hobbies. Life is just going on in the midst of the most serious political crisis of any of our lifetimes and the cognitive dissonance of that is making us feel a little bit crazy.

During the pandemic I binged watched a wonderful series called “A French Village” which chronicled the lives of the people in a small town during the Nazi occupation. It’s not a story about the terror of the Holocaust or even the brave Britons who lived through the blitz in England. This is about living day to day and adapting to fascist oppression as it becomes more and more dangerous and violent. The villagers still had to do business, shop (and later find food), the kids had to go to school, people made love and had babies — and they all had to confront at some point how they were going to deal with the occupiers. Some collaborated, some left, some resisted, some subverted and some just tried to get by. Through it all life went on, even under the Nazis, until it didn’t.

Obviously, we’re not in that situation. It’s only been 68 days since Trump took office and we still have a way to go before it’s clear that the system has completely broken down one way or another. But I think we can all sense that it’s much shakier than we anticipated.

It’s been evident for years now that the Republican Party as we once knew it has ceased to exist as anything but the political arm of Donald Trump’s MAGA movement. It no longer has a distinct ideology and exists purely to serve his wishes. And yes, the Democrats in Washington seem to be in a state of suspended animation. But I confess that I didn’t expect to see so many of our major institutions, from corporations to universities to elite law firms follow their lead. They are, for the most part, capitulating to the administration’s threats.

We might have expected corporations to resist being told how to run their businesses but dozens of them have eagerly complied with the crusade to ban DEI and abandon all attempts to fulfill the promise of the civil rights act. Men at Wall St firms tell reporters they are thrilled to be able to talk about “p**sy” in the workplace again. Law firms, meanwhile, having been told they will lose their access to the federal government including necessary security clearances due to their previous willingness to defend some of Donald Trump’s personal enemies have bowed down and agreed to do whatever the president orders them to do. Universities, meanwhile, are now allowing the federal government to dictate their policies under threat of losing federal funding. This was unexpected. These giant, wealthy institutions all have the ability to stand up to Trump and chose not to.

I am a little bit surprised that we haven’t seen more of an exodus from the big law firms. I suppose they all figure if the big bosses are terrified, they probably should be too. And I confess that I would have expected some energy from the college campuses but virtually none has materialized. According to this NBC report from Columbia University, the top target of Trump’s strong arm tactics, the students say they are tired after the demonstrations last spring and are terrified of what the government might do to them if they protest against it. Considering that students are being kidnapped, you can’t exactly blame them. Columbia mathematics professor Michael Thaddeus described the campus this way:

“Classes are continuing, athletic competition is continuing, the libraries are open. I was watching a campus tour go by outside. It’s just a weird combination of normal and very abnormal.”

Normal and abnormal. Life goes on.

I would be remiss if I didn’t point out that for all the capitulation of the institutions, the paralysis of the official political opposition and the fear and trepidation of employees and students who fear for their futures if they speak out, there is quite a bit of resistance building up out in the country.

Senator Bernie Sanders and Rep. Alexandria Ocasio Cortez have been on a “Fighting Oligarchy” tour that’s garnering unprecedented huge crowds, even for them. Democrats are hosting town halls in red districts all over the country. And voters are turning up at events in huge numbers and registering their unhappiness with what Trump and his cronies are doing. Smalls protests have been breaking out all over the country, including at Tesla showrooms while some big demonstrations are planned, starting this April 5th with a national mobilization sponsored by Indivisible. Grassroots resistance to Trump is ramping up.

Most of us are still watching the unfolding crisis from afar. But before too long what Trump and his accomplices are doing will start to impact us personally and we won’t be able to avoid it any longer. We’ll all have to make a conscious decision as to whether we will resist, collaborate, leave, or just try to keep our heads down until it’s over. Whatever we choose we should be very clear in our own minds that while life does go on in the midst of a political crisis, the country is being changed in some fundamental ways that are not going to be easy to reverse. This nightmare is real and it isn’t going away.

He knows it. So should we.

Salon