Skip to content

Digby's Hullabaloo Posts

Musk’s Mass Murder

He could go down in history as one of the worst

Elon Musk’s entrepreneurial philosophy when he acquires a company is to immediately shut down everything and then restore a few once they get the lay of the land and determine what he thinks is necessary. We saw that at Twitter when he came in and fired everyone, determined that any kind of moderation was unnecessary and it’s now overrun with bots, disinformation, foreign propaganda and Nazis. He likes that. He fired the disaster team that made Twitter an important resource during those times, getting out information you could rely on as real. As we found out during the LA fires, it’s completely useless for that purpose now.

He thinks the United States federal government is just like twitter. For instance he said this just the other night:

“Regulations, basically, should be default gone,” Musk said. “Not default there, default gone. And if it turns out that we missed the mark on a regulation, we can always add it back in.”

“These regulations are added willy-nilly all the time. So we’ve just got to do a wholesale, spring cleaning of regulation and get the government off the backs of everyday Americans so people can get things done,” Musk said, adding later: “If the government has millions of regulations holding everyone back, well, it’s not freedom. We’ve got to restore freedom.”

As we’ve seen with USAID, he’s also willing to completely shut down agencies he says have engaged in fraud with no notice. I’ve heard some fatuous Republicans on television saying that they can always “restore” the functions that are really important. Sure. Republicans love helping foreigners.

What are the odds that this is going to end well?

Two weeks into President Trump’s sweeping freeze on foreign aid, H.I.V. groups abroad have not received any funding, jeopardizing the health of more than 20 million people, including 500,000 children. Subsequent waivers from the State Department have clarified that the work can continue, but the funds and legal paperwork to do so are still missing.

With the near closure of the American aid agency known as U.S.A.I.D. and its recall of officers posted abroad, there is little hope that the situation will resolve quickly, experts warned.

H.I.V. treatment and services were funded through the President’s Emergency Plan for AIDS Relief, or PEPFAR, a $7.5 billion program that was frozen along with all foreign aid on Mr. Trump’s first day in office.

[…]

Without treatment, millions of people with H.I.V. would be at risk of severe illness and premature death. The loss of treatment also threatens to reverse the dramatic progress made against H.I.V. in recent years and could spur the emergence of drug-resistant strains of H.I.V.; both outcomes could have a global impact, including in the United States.

There are very serious consequences for the impulsive, wrecking ball mode of government that Project 2025 and Elon Musk are carrying out. They don’t care. Musk is a sociopath and Russell Vought (who is clearly guiding this behind the scenes as well) is a racist white nationalist religious fanatic who no doubt thinks that people with HIV were asking for it. Neither they, nor Trump, care at all if 20 million people die. In fact, I suspect they think it’s probably a good thing since the sick are a burden on the rich people (producers) who are responsible for everything good in this world.

America First

He really thinks the Palestinians are pets who can be rehomed to a “farm in the country.” He’s doubling down. (I wonder if everyone is aware that Trump’s new Ambassador to Israel,Mike Huckabee, has said that there’s no such thing as a Palestinian? Yeah…)

This is awfully cute:

 Israeli Defense Minister Israel Katz on Thursday proposed offering residents the right to resettle in any country that will have them after U.S. President Donald Trump‘s plan to take over Gaza and relocate Palestinians to neighboring countries.

Saying the people of Gaza should have the same right to freedom of movement and migration that was the norm around the world, Katz announced on X that the plan would provide a range of exit options, including via land crossings, as well as special arrangements to depart by sea and air.

He singled out Canada as a top potential destination due to what he said was its “structured immigration program” and previously stated willingness to accept migrants from Gaza.

“I have instructed the IDF to prepare a plan that will allow any resident of Gaza who wishes to leave to do so, to any country willing to receive them,” he said in his proposal in which he also threw down the gauntlet to countries critical of the way Israel had conducted its military offensive in Gaza,” wrote Katz.

“Countries such as Spain, Ireland, Norway and others, which have falsely accused Israel over its actions in Gaza, are legally obligated to allow Gazans to enter their territory. Their hypocrisy will be exposed if they refuse.”

“I welcome President Trump’s bold initiative, which can create extensive opportunities for those in Gaza who wish to leave, assist them in resettling in host countries, and support long-term reconstruction efforts in a demilitarized, threat-free Gaza after Hamas — an effort that will take many years,” he added.

Why not the US??? I think people in the Palm Beach area would be thrilled to welcome them. Or Arkansas, Mike Huckabee’s state. Think of all the jobs it would create building the fancy new homes for them. Why should Canada get all that money?

Marco Rubio and his Press Secretary Barbie both said that he meant that the ethnic cleansing would be temporary. Trump seems to have a different plan in mind, though. It’s clear that he means for them to be “resettled” in “the region.” But don’t worry their homes will be modern. And maybe, if they’re very good boys and girls, they’ll be allowed to visit Trump Gaza Golf Resort, maybe even work there a janitors some day.

The New York Times:

When President Trump announced his proposal for the United States to take ownership of Gaza on Tuesday, he shocked even senior members of his own White House and government.

While his announcement looked formal and thought-out — he read the plan from a sheet of paper — his administration had not done even the most basic planning to examine the feasibility of the idea, according to four people with knowledge of the discussions, who were not authorized to speak publicly.

It wasn’t only the Americans who were scrambling; the announcement came as just as much of a surprise to Mr. Trump’s Israeli visitors. Soon before they walked out for their joint news conference on Tuesday, Mr. Trump surprised Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu of Israel by telling him he planned to announce the Gaza ownership idea, according to two people briefed on their interactions.

Inside the U.S. government, there had been no meetings with the State Department or Pentagon, as would normally occur for any serious foreign policy proposal, let alone one of such magnitude. There had been no working groups. The Defense Department had produced no estimates of the troop numbers required, or cost estimates, or even an outline of how it might work.

There was little beyond an idea inside the president’s head.

Nobody knew about it before he rolled it out. He is unstable and I mean that literally. His impulsivity is more childlike every day. Like this kid:

Pushback

BREAKING: we just blocked Musk & Trump out of the Treasury systems! Court order just secured — big win by us at @sddaction.bsky.social & our partners including @publiccitizen.bsky.social!

Norm Eisen (@normeisen.bsky.social) 2025-02-06T14:54:05.323Z

This is written by Jay Michaelson a visiting professor priest at Harvard:

 I’m posting in response to the many sincerely anguished claims that not enough is being done to stop Trump.  This is not reflected in the facts.

– Represented by Public Citizen Litigation Group and State Democracy Defenders Fund, the Alliance for Retired Americans, the American Federation of Government Employees (AFGE), and the Service Employees International Union (SEIU) filed suit on Monday against the Treasury Department “for sharing confidential data with the so-called Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE), run by Elon Musk.”  Go to Public Citizen’s website to learn all about this lawsuit, which is very likely to prevail.

– On USAID, appearing with other Democratic lawmakers outside USAID offices on Monday, Representative Jamie Raskin (D-Md.) shouted, “Elon Musk, you didn’t create USAID. The United States Congress did for the American people … like Elon Musk did not create USAID, he doesn’t have the power to destroy it. And who’s going to stop him? We are…  This a constitutional crisis that we are in today.”   Lawsuits have also been filed in this matter, and are also likely to prevail.

– Hakeem Jeffries has announced lawsuits have been filed regarding the firings of inspectors general.

– On Jan 21, Democracy Forward, was filed at 12:01 p.m. ET on Monday and accused Elon Musk’s DOGE of being a “shadow operation led by unelected billionaires” that flouts federal transparency rules.  That should win.

– National Security Counselors filed a suit arguing that DOGE meets the requirements to be a federal advisory committee and is therefore legally required to have “fairly balanced” representation, keep regular minutes of meetings and allow public access to meetings.  Clearly accurate.

– Eighteen state attorneys general and a slew of immigrants’ rights groups brought swift legal action against Trump after he signed his executive order seeking to ban birthright citizenship for some children born in the U.S., arguing that it violates the Fourteenth Amendment.  Obviously, clearly unconstitutional.

– “Schedule F” has been challenged in court by the National Treasury Employees Union, which represents employees in 37 agencies and departments.  

– Several immigrant rights groups in the United States, as well as the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU), have filed a lawsuit challenging President Donald Trump’s ban on asylum claims.

– GLAD Law and the National Center For Lesbian Rights (NCLR) have sued to stop Trump’s ban on trans people in the military.

And there are many more

Yes, there are Trump judges in the courts, and if Aileen Cannon types get these cases, Trump may prevail.  But most judges are not like her.  These actions are clearly illegal and/or unconstitutional, and they WILL be stopped.

Whether Elon and Trump will abide by court orders remains to be seen. That’s the big test. But there is action on that front.

The big question hovering over all of this is what the Supremes will finally do. JV Last had a rather chilling thought on all that yesterday:

Under the current status quo, the Supreme Court is the final arbiter of the law in the American system. Trump will test this proposition. Take that to the bank.

At which point SCOTUS will have two options:

  1. Find against Trump and hope that Trump agrees to be bound by the Court’s opinion; or
  2. Let Trump have his way, even if it is blatantly unconstitutional—because they believe that Trump will defy their order and will get away with it, because no other power center in the government will be willing to enforce SCOTUS’s ruling.

Real talk: I’m not sure which of those pathways would be more prudent.

It depends on circumstance. How popular is Trump at the time of the ruling? Does the case concern a subject that has great salience for the public? What would the vote count be, 9–0? 5–4? Do Democrats control any branches of government?

Because here’s the thing: When we get to that final showdown, it’s for all the marbles. If Trump can successfully defy a SCOTUS order, then American democracy is over.

That’s enough to keep you awake tonight isn’t it? He thinks the Supremes should keep their powder dry and I couldn’t disagree more. They should vote 7-2 (Alito and Thomas are hopeless) against Trump, no question. I doubt it will go down that way, but that’s the best case scenario. We’re already so far down the rabbit hole that there’s no margin in being “prudent” for another day. It’s all on the line already.

Joke ‘Em If They Can’t Take A F___

Join the fight or be political roadkill

First: Get busy. Talk is cheap. Action is better (and empowering). Even if it’s just leaving a voice message with your representatives, filling out an online response form or sending an efax. To Republicans and Democrats. Regularly. Not one and done.

No, it’s not as sexy as going to a big rally with your tribe or launching that nonprofit you’ve been rolling around in your head. Neither is hunkering down with an M4 in a cold, wet foxhole. Deal with it. The unsexy stuff matters:

Back when we had a Democratic congressman here, I knew the staff and would call the office to gauge the temperature on hot issues. I’d ask how the calls were running on a bill progressives wanted passed. Ten to one against. “Where are the Democrats?” they asked, exasperated. They’d voted, reset their politics to cruise control and went back to complaining.

Do that now and Musk-Trump-MAGA will eat you for lunch. But just as Trump is a blustering fraud, so is their mob-speak. Their goal here is simple: Bark loudly enough that the other dog rolls over on its back and pees in the air in submission.

That’s gonna be a no from me, dawg

Musk-Trump-MAGA is barking loudly at Bill Kristol and Sarah Longwell of The Bulwark. They’re being attacked online, sometimes with threats. But they’re not submitting.

Longwell writes:

Bill isn’t alone in receiving these weird smears and creepy attacks. The New York TimesPolitico, the BBC, the Associated PressBen Stiller, Orlando Bloom, Jean-Claude Van Damme—all have also been accused of receiving USAID money for various normal things they did that Elon and/or his online fanboys do not like.

I can’t possibly say this in simpler terms: They’re just making it all up.

I’D LIKE TO POINT OUT that this is a first for us as Americans. Never before has a presidential administration so openly wielded the power of the federal government as a blunt-force instrument to be used against fellow Americans, journalism outlets, and, yes, its political rivals. We’re in a new place now.

Their working theory seems to be that maybe they can cow their critics and the media itself into submission. Maybe they can more easily turn the government into a plaything for their own personal enrichment.

That’s the playbook. Here’s how it plays out in three steps:

First they threaten you. Then they create conspiracy theories about you. Then they hound you with an online mob to make sure you fall in line.

That’s gonna be a no from me, dawg.

You can join the fight or be political roadkill.

Musk Is Malware

Implement a political version of Malwarebytes

Musk is the living embodiment of AI: a broken, tech-bro tool that inserts itself into everyone’s life unsolicited and makes everything worse. — Alex Winter

Donald Trump is acting like he’s a king the way he fooled the the New York Times (1976) into thinking he was a successful developer. The way he pretended to be a successful businessman on TV. It was a con job then. It’s a con job now.

Before we go any further, let’s review Ezra Klein’s “Don’t Believe Him” commentary from the other day on Donald Trump’s efforts to snow people into allowing him to act like a king despite the real limitations of presidential power. Like every move in Trump’s life, it’s a “fake it till you make it” put on. I had not seen the video version until last night and found it a useful tonic. Consider watching it a “take a deep breath” act of self care.

Now then, despite Alex Winter’s pithy observations about tech-bro emotional brokenness and Paul Rosenberg’s “The intelligence is artificial. The stupidity is real,” the damage Elon Musk is doing in D.C. is also real. “Any pretense of public service has been abandoned,” writes Matt Ford at The New Republic. Musk is malware. Our goal now must be to implement a political version of Malwarebytes.

We took concerned calls over the weekend at our local headquarters asking where were congressional Democrats at the end of last week when Musk raided USAID, etc.? Short answer: at home in their districts. DNC members were in a scheduled multi-day meeting electing new leaders. That was the point of Musk’s timing. The “opposition,” as he calls them were unavailable.

Since returning to D.C. , however, Democrats have begun to rally. And to hold rallies:

We are at the US Treasury Department standing with our allies DEMANDING that tech oligarchs stay the hell away from essential programs like Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid!

Social Security Works (@socialsecurityworks.org) 2025-02-04T22:08:26.200Z

Sen. Brian Schatz of Hawaii announced a hold on all Trump nominees until Musk’s attacks on USAID, a vital tool for projecting U.S. soft power, are reversed.

Schatz organized an effort to stall Senate approval of Project 2025 kingpin Russell Vought:

At least three dozen Democratic senators will take part in a 30-hour talkathon to show they are fighting to stop Vought, a key author of Project 2025, the Heritage Foundation’s far-right policy blueprint for Trump’s second term. Project 2025 calls for drastic cuts to Medicare, Medicaid and Social Security. It also calls for a freeze on all federal grants, something Trump tried to impose last week but had to rescind because it sure looked illegal and left countless federal programs in disarray.

Some friends were skeptical of the 50 states rallies held on Wednesday (they came out of nowhere and sparked concerns about false-flags), but they seem to have arisen organically like the George Floyd protests. And they took off around the nation.

50 states. 1 day. Thousands rally at state capitals & federal offices opposing Project 2025 & recent exec orders. Issues: USAID cuts, immigration, reproductive rights. Live updates from Peace Monument DC ↗️ www.usatoday.com/story/news/n… #50501Movement

JenRemsik (@jenremsik.bsky.social) 2025-02-05T17:41:03.174Z

St. Paul, Minn., resist. It was so great to see love for humanity alongside disgust for foolish and dangerous leadership. #50501

Glenn Hansen (@hansenhousecomm.bsky.social) 2025-02-05T23:04:36.902Z

TODAY: At least 100 people are rallying at the Ohio Statehouse to protest against President Donald Trump & Project 2025. This is part of the nationwide ‘50501 Movement,’ whose organizers say they oppose fascism & Trump’s executive orders and policies.@ohiocapitaljournal.com

Morgan Trau (@morgantrau.bsky.social) 2025-02-05T21:25:21.154Z

Protestors have gathered outside of the Indianapolis Statehouse as part of the “50 States” anti-Trump protest. #hoosiersky #news #indy #indianapolis

Noe Padilla (@noepadilla.bsky.social) 2025-02-05T17:28:10.501Z

Some early scenes from the 50 States 50 Marches rally in Springfield, IL on Wednesday

Alex Degman (@alexdegman.bsky.social) 2025-02-05T18:29:13.267Z

"Between 200 to 300 people rallied at the 50 States, 50 Protests, 1 Day rally on the steps of Kentucky's State Capitol in Frankfort Wednesday, Feb 5, 2025 to call for action to reign in President Donald Trump's executive actions since he (was) re-elected to office." – Matt Stone/Courier Journal

My Friend Kaylen (@myfriendkaylen.bsky.social) 2025-02-05T21:28:01.414Z

Don’t get mad. Get busy.

(h/t AL)

Musk’s Cyberpunks Have Infiltrated NOAA

Cuts are coming:

Staffers with Elon Musk’s “department of government efficiency” (Doge) reportedly entered the headquarters of the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (Noaa) in Silver Spring, Maryland, and the Department of Commerce in Washington DC today, inciting concerns of downsizing at the agency.

“They apparently just sort of walked past security and said: ‘Get out of my way,’ and they’re looking for access for the IT systems, as they have in other agencies,” said Andrew Rosenberg, a former Noaa official who is now a fellow at the University of New Hampshire. “They will have access to the entire computer system, a lot of which is confidential information.”

Project 2025, written by several former Trump staffers, has called for the agency to be “broken up and downsized”, claiming the agency is “harmful to US prosperity” for its role in climate science.

Staffers with Elon Musk’s “department of government efficiency” (Doge) reportedly entered the headquarters of the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (Noaa) in Silver Spring, Maryland, and the Department of Commerce in Washington DC today, inciting concerns of downsizing at the agency.

“They apparently just sort of walked past security and said: ‘Get out of my way,’ and they’re looking for access for the IT systems, as they have in other agencies,” said Andrew Rosenberg, a former Noaa official who is now a fellow at the University of New Hampshire. “They will have access to the entire computer system, a lot of which is confidential information.” …

Rosenberg noted it had been a longtime goal of corporations that rely on Noaa data to prevent the agency from making the data public, instead of giving it directly to private corporations that create products based on it, such as weather forecasting services.

What’s the objective?

Project 2025 includes about four pages on NOAA and the National Weather Service. That part was written by Thomas F. Gilman, who was an official in Trump’s Commerce Department.

The document describes NOAA as a primary component “of the climate change alarm industry” and said it “should be broken up and downsized.” 

The National Weather Service, one of six NOAA offices, provides weather and climate forecasts and warnings. The National Hurricane Center is part of the National Weather Service within NOAA.

Project 2025 would not outright end the National Weather Service. It says the agency “should focus on its data-gathering services,” and “should fully commercialize its forecasting operations.”

It said that “commercialization of weather technologies should be prioritized to ensure that taxpayer dollars are invested in the most cost-efficient technologies for high quality research and weather data.” Investing in commercial partners will increase competition, Project 2025 said.

Project 2025 also said the National Weather Service should become a “performance-based organization” held accountable for achieving specific results, even if the head of the agency must “deviate from government rules” to achieve those results.

The document said little about the National Hurricane Center. It said the administration should “review the work of the National Hurricane Center” and that “data collected by the department should be presented neutrally, without adjustments intended to support any one side in the climate debate.”

Sure, who needs reliable, science based weather and climate research and forecasting? And anyway, somebody should be able to make a buck off of it, amirite?

The fossil fuel industry would like to get rid of all climate science and under Musk and Trump they may succeed. But climate change is happening whether they like it or not.

Trump’s Top Hatchet Woman Takes Her Seat

Bondi made her first move and it’s purely about vengeance. Trump must be so pleased:

Attorney General Pam Bondi spent her first day on the job Wednesday redirecting the Justice Department’s significant law enforcement authority toward addressing President Donald Trump’s grievances with the agency, making her allegiance to his agenda clear in a series of strongly worded directives.

Despite pledging during her confirmation hearing that “politics will not play a part” in her decision-making, Bondi created a “Weaponization Working Group” to review instances of what she described as “politicized justice” – starting with the federal criminal cases brought against Trump by special counsel Jack Smith. She also pledged to examine what she alleged was federal cooperation in the criminal and civil investigations of Trump in New York — even though they were carried out by state authorities, Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg and New York Attorney General Letitia James.

Bondi ended the federal moratorium on the death penalty, paused federal justice grant funding for sanctuary cities and demanded “zealous advocacy” of the president’s agenda from the department’s more than 10,000 lawyers.

“Any attorney who because of their personal political views or judgments declines to sign a brief or appear in court, refuses to advance good-faith arguments on behalf of the administration, or otherwise delays or impedes the Department’s mission will be subject to discipline and potentially termination, consistent with applicable law,” Bondi wrote in one directive she signed Wednesday.

All those “norms” Merrick Garland protected are now in the rubbish can. That worked out well.

All I can say is that I’m very glad Joe Biden pardoned his family and the J6 Committee members. Anyone who believes that doing that somehow empowers Trump or that it was unnecessary is a fool. The only reason Biden himself is safe is because of the Supreme Court’s immunity ruling to protect Trump.

Cheered Around The World

https://twitter.com/atrupar/status/1887165911200649675

Yeah, it went over really well:

Palestinian president says Trump’s plan would be ‘a serious violation of international law’
Hamas says Trump plan to take over Gaza will pour ‘oil on the fire’
Saudi Arabia says no Israel normalization without Palestinian state
Jordan’s king urged efforts ‘to stop settlement activities’
UAE ‘stressed categorical rejection of any infringement of Palestians’ rights’
France warns against any displacement of Palestinians
UK says Palestinians should ‘must be allowed home’
Germany says Gaza, West Bank and East Jerusalem belong to Palestinians
Turkish foreign minister says Trump’s Gaza comments are ‘unacceptable’
China says it opposes the forced relocation of people in Gaza
Houthi leader says Trump’s Gaza plan represents ‘American arrogance’

Click the link to read what they said.

Nobody thinks it ‘s a good idea except for Trump, his flunkies and Bibi Netanyahu.

Repeat, Repeat, Repeat

The cacophony of political news is deafening. But Democrats have got to decide on a few simple phrases to say in unison and repeat cover and over again.

This is from “The Frame Lab” newsletter and I think it’s a step in the right direction:

Democrats face three immediate challenges:

  1. Grabbing the public’s attention
  2. Hammering the right frame
  3. Repeating it over and over again

Data for Progress, a progressive polling firm, suggests that framing Musk’s actions as “stealing from you” resonates strongly with voters. From Data for Progress:

Additionally, while saying DOGE will cut programs to “give tax breaks to giant corporations and billionaires like Musk” effectively decreases DOGE’s favorability, a message that combines “steal from you” and “give tax breaks” has an even greater negative impact on voters’ opinion on DOGE, particularly among Independents whose views on DOGE shifted 14 points more unfavorably on net with the combined message.

I believe the frame of “theft” can also unite us as a country against intruders who unjustly take our shared treasure and threaten our prosperity. The core message remains: the wealthiest man in the country is trying to steal what belongs to every American. He doesn’t need anything, yet he’s still pilfering from those who need it most.

I would combine that with “Nobody voted for Musk” which gives some wobbly Trump voters the ability to turn on the agenda without admitting they were dupes which seems to be very difficult for them to do. (MAGA means never having to say you’re sorry…)

Focusing on Musk right now in these early days makes the most sense. He’s not popular and he’s acting like a crazy man.

The Conspiracy Theory O’ The Day

I have often noticed that the MAGA wingnuts believe that almost everyone in the country (except for trans kids, feminists and Black women) actually agrees with them but all the cheating and rigging is keeping the massive MAGA majority from being heard.

Well, today it was revealed that Politico missed a payroll because of a technical glitch and they decided that it was because USAID is funding the liberal media.

The White House “confirmed” it (probably through reading Twitter trolls) the same way they have confirmed that USAID spent $50 million or $100 million on condoms in Gaza.

According to Fox, Politico has received $8million from the feds over the years for something, but only $44,000 from USAID.

That news morphed into this:

Look who endorses this daft idea:

It’s one big simulation put together by our Martian overlords to keep us happy while they rape our children and drink our blood.