I listened to James Carville Sunday morning on Jen Psaki’s show and read his Op-Ed in the NY Times. I got the impression from Psaki that his advice is being taken very seriously by Democrats. He believes that we need to stop caring about Donald Trump’s assault on reason and the Constitution and concentrate on kitchen table issues. He says that when people are suffering greatly nobody cares that he’s a corrupt criminal and an enemy of democracy so Democrats shouldn’t talk about it anymore. And he cautions that denouncing the other party and its voters is “no way to win an election.” (Donald Trump would like a word …) He says that Trump won on his economic message.
Carville advised Democrats to focus on opposing Republican party economic policies but they also need to offer “wildly popular” economic policies that will appeal to people. He suggests issues such as the codification of Roe v. Wade, a higher minimum wage and support for H1B visas to “expedite entry for high-performing talent and for those who will bring business into our nation.”
Obviously opposing the GOP economic message is vital. No one would argue otherwise. Minimum wage is a no-brainer. And sure, support for codification of Roe v. Wade as an “economic” issue is worth doing but it’s going to take a whole lot of explaining to make people understand why. The H1B visa support is a recipe for handing more political power to Elon Musk but sure, what could go wrong?
I have no idea what the proper political strategy going forward might be. I thought that most people would reject a lying, narcissistic, corrupt criminal who incited a riot to stop the peaceful transfer of power but they didn’t. According to the data we’re beginning to see from the election, most voters didn’t think he did anything disqualifying and don’t believe he’ll fulfill any of his extremist promises in the next four years. They just dislike the Democrats more than they dislike him. For the moment.
Carville believes that’s because so many people are in economic distress and if that’s true we have to assume that the ways we have traditionally used to measure that no longer work. So maybe he’s right that the suffering is intense and the Democrats erred in not fully acknowledging it and spending too much time discussing issues like their corrupt opponent’s rank unfitness for office.
But let’s just say I’m a bit skeptical that unless we’re mired in a major recession, which no one should want, this will inspire all those voters who stayed home to rush to the ballot box in two or four years. In fact, I suspect that Trump’s going to be seen as the triumphant leader who brought back the economy from the depths that people like James Carville and others are intent upon validating despite the fact that it isn’t true.
Trump is inheriting a powerful nation with full employment and a strong growing economy. Inflation has been tamed although people are still smarting from prices being higher than they were four years ago and the shortage of housing is a serious problem. No economy is ever perfect — there are always sectors that are under stress — and poverty remains an issue for far too many. But when you look objectively at this economy, it is good.
Nonetheless, we have all decided that it is to our benefit to cater to the vibes and so that’s going to be the strategy. But I wonder if it’s not fighting the last war. Unless Trump follows through on his tariffs and deportations and the economy collapses people are going to credit him with the good economy that already exists because he will be taking credit for it!
Frankly, I’m pinning my hopes on the fact that Trump and his people are imbeciles who will overreach in ways that nobody can ignore. It’s not a bad bet. Otherwise, Democrats may be burying themselves for a long time to come.
But as I said, I no longer have any faith in my ability to prescribe strategy. Maybe going back to the old “kitchen table issues” advice is the way to go. I had thought that we were living in a new world in which a threat of authoritarianism and oligarchy combined with a media landscape that’s completely changed the way people get and absorb information might require some fresh thinking but I don’t see much evidence that the elite strategists think that’s necessary.
So kitchen table issues it is. Prepare for the Trump victory tour.
Update—
Who cares about this? Nobody: