Your Lyin’ Eyes

It’s depressing that you have to get this elementary with the American press, but you do. There is something called cause and effect. Any of you out there who don’t know what that means can use your friend, Mr Google, to find out what it is.

New Orleans is a largely black city. Most of those who did not evacuate were poor African Americans. In the day after Katrina, pictures of victims standing on rooftops emerged. Heroic rescues were filmed. In short order we saw pictures of looting — which immediately sent the wingnuts into a frenzy. This immediately led to cries for martial law — stories of shooting, killing and rape followed. (Interestingly, this story in which photojournalists on the scene were interviewed early on indicates that while looting and theft were common, the violence they observed was mostly perpetrated by nervous police.)

We do not know to what extent these stories inhibited the relief effort, but there is evidence that they did. A real post mortem should be able to sort that out.

Because of the paranoid fear of violence and many other things such as the necessary National Guard equipment being deployed to Iraq and a federal agency charged with stepping in where local and state governments are overwhelmed being incompetent in virtually every way possible — the conditions in New Orleans deteriorated rapidly as basic necessities and evacuations were delayed.

Let’s make it simple for everyone. The reports of violence were overblown. The reports of misery, dehydration, delayed medical care, no food and wretched conditions were not. And it is highly likely that it was the first that led, at least in part, to the second.

Yet, the New York Times fails to make that distinction and pretends that the the desperation was overblown.

During the first few days, as local officials grappled with the overwhelming disaster, Mr. Nagin and Mr. Compass were outspoken about how desperate the situation in their city was, though some of those statements are now coming under scrutiny, with some critics saying they exaggerated the situation.

An editorial in The Times Picayune today faulted the two New Orleans officials for their leadership during those first few days, and for their public statements about the direness of the situation.

“It’s understandable that in the tense and fractured days after Katrina, frightened people reported rumor as fact, and soldiers, police and even elected officials believed what they heard and passed it on.” the editorial said. “In the hell that descended after Katrina, almost anything, no matter how horrific, seemed possible.

“But now that we know better, it’s essential that people like Mayor Nagin and Superintendent Compass set the record straight, just as forcefully. That might mean saying, ‘I spoke too soon” or even, ‘I exaggerated,’ ” the editorial said.

The newspaper said that during an interview by Oprah Winfrey, Mr. Compass said “that babies were being raped.”

“Thank God it didn’t happen,” the editorial said.

The Times-Picayune editorial was quite specific. The New York Times was not.

And that, predictably, plays into this quixotic quest by right-wing bloggers to prove that the entire disaster was overblown, not just the violence. That is not going to fly.

Here’s a little reminder:

I urge everyone to click on the BagNews picture in the left column or click here and take a look at the amazing images shot by Alan Chin in New Orleans. He’s the one who shot the iconic picture of the elderly African American woman wrapped in the American flag. There can be no doubt of what happened in the after math of Katrina — horrible human suffering caused by a massive government failure.

The only question is why.

.