CNN blows up the Melting Pot
by digby
According to a CNN/Opinion Research Corporation national survey, the vast majority believe that most immigrants are basically good, honest people who are hard-working. However, nearly seven in ten say that immigrants are a burden on the taxpayer, 62 percent think they add to the crime problem, and 59 percent believe they take jobs away from Americans. The poll, released Wednesday, asks about all people who have immigrated from other countries in the past ten years, and not just about illegal immigrants in the U.S. “The results may explain why most Americans think that the policies that made the U.S. a ‘melting pot’ strengthened the country a century ago but do not make the country stronger today,” says CNN Polling Director Keating Holland.
Well there you have it. “Most Americans” think immigrants are “basically” good, honest people but they are also criminals and indolent leeches who are stealing our jobs. That makes sense.
I don’t know exactly why CNN thought this was worth doing, but if their polling is correct, it’s apparent that “most Americans” are a bunch of nativist jerks. Perhaps that’s true. It’s certainly always been the case that Americans have always tried to pull the ladder up behind them, whether it was the English settlers to the Germans, then the Germans to the Italians and the Slavs or everybody to the Chinese and other Asians. As for Latinos, well, they have always been here and we just use them as scapegoats whenever we feel like kicking somebody. Apparently, that would be now.
CNN’s definitely stirring the shit with this, though, at a time when it’s terribly irresponsible to do so. When they say “immigrants” in the current climate, most people think they are talking about Hispanics. If they are going to do this, they really need to get specific and ask people if they are talking about Indian doctors or Polish construction workers or Jamaican business owners when they talk about this. My neighbors are French and Irish immigrants. Are they included in this indictment? Or is this just the usual plain old bigotry against Mexicans. I think it would be very helpful to be precise in this debate. You can’t talk about this unless you understand the real issue.
.