The Polarization Era
by digby
John Judis on GOP triumphalism:
Has the rightward shift laid the groundwork for a new Republican majority?If the conservative trend among the electorate endures for a decade, yes, then Republicans will be back in the driving seat in American politics. But the conservative trend after 2008 was not the result of the gradual erosion of the liberal-moderate majority, but of the failure of the Obama administration to stem the downturn that began in 2008. If the economy revives, or if it doesn’t, and if a Republican president and Congress take office in 2012 and fail to revive it, then the trend toward conservatism will halt, and you may even see the kind of shift leftward that took place in 2006 and 2008. Of course, Cost could argue that the kind of programs that Republicans are proposing will revive the economy and enjoy the same kind of popularity as social security. I have my doubts that these programs, which mostly consist of turning back the Keynesian clock, will do the trick.
Cost argues that redistricting, which will be under Republican control in many states, could help to ensure a GOP majority in Congress. Certainly it’ll help, but the Democratic redistricting as a result of the 1990 elections didn’t prevent Republicans from capturing the House and the Senate in 1994. As I suggested in my post-election piece, the Obama administration’s failure to seize the political opportunity afforded by the Great Recession has not necessarily opened the way to a new Republican majority. More likely, it will lead to a period where the two parties exchange power, and where neither can establish a long-lasting majority.
I greatly suspect that will be the case. The nation (and the world) is in transition and the system and the elites who run it have proven to be craven or incompetent to navigate it. Until either circumstances change or one Party is able to make a lasting case for its philosophy (or both) we are going to be fighting this out election to election. Everybody just needs to fasten their seat belts and prepare for a bumpy flight.
So please, let’s not hear any more talk of “realignments.” I think it’s quite clear that we don’t know we’ve had a realignment until long after it’s taken place, so it’s just premature triumphalism on the part of both parties when they do it. And it leads to political errors, as we saw in 2009.
.