They’ve never stopped fighting the civil warby digby
My column for Salon this morning is about John Kelly and the civil war:
Back in 1990 as the nation prepared to launch the first Gulf War,Ken Burn’s epic documentary series “The Civil War” was broadcast for the first time on PBS and, by all accounts, it had quite an effect on some of the top military brass. Then Chairman of the Joint Chiefs Colin Powell recalled in his memoirs that he had told General Norman Schwartzkopf, the Commander-in-chief of the United States Central Command, the leader of the coalition forces, “at least now people will know what war is about.”
Schwarzkopf recalled in his memoirs that Powell had related to him that after he’d asked for more troops and time at one point, an “official” who’d watched the series compared him to General George McClellan, the first commanding Union General known for his overly cautious strategy. The official reportedly declared, “My God, he’s got all the force he needs. Why won’t he just attack?” Schwarzkopf wrote that the person in question “was a civilian who knew next to nothing about military affairs, but he’d been watching the Civil War documentary on public television and was now an expert.” Twenty pages later he mentioned that then Secretary of Defense Dick Cheney sent him “The Civil War” series on video just before they commenced the bombing making it obvious who the unqualified civilian had been.
Apparently, the brass and the warhawks were all greatly influenced by this documentary series which may explain why General John Kelly sent a little shockwave through the country when he echoed his boss’s obtuse “both sides” comments about Charlottesville by telling Laura Ingraham in an interview on Monday night that “the lack of an ability to compromise led to the Civil War, and men and women of good faith on both sides made their stand where their conscience had them make their stand” as part of a defense of confederate General Robert E. Lee.
White House press secretary Sarah Huckabee Sanders defended his comments from the podium on Tuesday morning saying:
“I don’t know that I’m going to get into debating the Civil War, but I do know that many historians, including Shelby Foote in Ken Burns’ famous Civil War documentary, agree that a failure to compromise was a cause of the Civil War. There are a lot of historians that think that and there are a lot of different versions of those compromises.”
Author and civil war buff Ta-Nahesi Coates gave a twitter lesson on all the compromises that were attempted in advance of the civil war and civil war historians stepped up to take issue with Kelly’s comments.
New York magazine’s Jonathan Chait explained that Shelby Foote’s analysis, and the Burns series generally (which was made nearly 30 years ago) is a misrepresentation of the facts but also a sadly common misconception among the American people even today. He points out that “a 2011 poll found that 48 percent of Americans identify states’ rights as the war’s main conflict, while only 38 percent identify it as slavery.”
Despite America fighting a bloody civil war over slavery, it still hasn’t been honestly dealt with in our culture.
The first Republican president dealt with this subject of “compromise” in 1860 at the Cooper Union in New York. He spoke for a long time about the question of the expansion of slavery and what the founders intended when they wrote the constitution about federal power and jurisdiction. And then he addressed the Southern people, pointing out that their contemptuous attitude toward the other parties made them deaf and blind to their own self-interest, their unwillingness to negotiate in good faith and even accept when they had been granted a victory.
He laid out each moment in the fraught history of “compromise” over slavery and showed how the southern leadership had refused to take yes for an answer. And he explained, with great insight, why:
The question recurs, what will satisfy them?
Simply this: We must not only let them alone, but we must somehow, convince them that we do let them alone. This, we know by experience, is no easy task. We have been so trying to convince them from the very beginning of our organization, but with no success. In all our platforms and speeches we have constantly protested our purpose to let them alone; but this has had no tendency to convince them. Alike unavailing to convince them, is the fact that they have never detected a man of us in any attempt to disturb them.
These natural, and apparently adequate means all failing, what will convince them? This, and this only: cease to call slavery wrong, and join them in calling it right. And this must be done thoroughly – done in acts as well as in words. Silence will not be tolerated – we must place ourselves avowedly with them.
If this sounds familiar it’s because the political faction that organized itself around slavery still exists and carries that chip on its collective shoulder to this day. What Lincoln described in the Cooper Union speech is the attitude and temperament of the racist tribe of America. They call themselves Republicans today but until 50 years ago they would have identified as Democrats.
Today the racist tribe is once again as paranoid and angry as it was before the civil war. And as they did then, they are cheating and lying constantly, from blatantly suppressing the vote to breaking democratic norms and rules to using every lever of institutional machinery to preserve their power, such as the stunning refusal to fill a Supreme Court seat named by a president of the opposing party.
As we’ve seen, this isn’t new. But it’s as dangerous as it’s ever been. The country isn’t going to physically break in two this time and the issues around racism and modernism are more diffuse. It’s a different nation and a different world. But the stakes are actually much higher: it appears they’ve even decided to enlist foreign actors to help them defeat their rivals if that’s what it takes. They will accept nothing less than total and complete fealty to their beliefs and ideology and if the country comes apart, that’s a price they’ve always been more than willing to pay.
Indeed, it’s becoming clear that when Donald Trump promised to make America great again, he was talking about the Confederate States of America, not the good old USA.
.