It’s much more logical that it was a conservative
I clerked at the Supreme Court. Last night, I assumed a liberal clerk leaked the draft opinion overturning Roe. Now I think MUCH more likely it was leaked by a conservative fanatically committed to every word of Alito’s monstrous opinion.
Timing: This draft was circulated in Feb. If a liberal was mad about it, why wait until April to send it to Politico? The op will be out in June. What are the benefits of releasing it early? And a BIG downside – the focus on the leak itself instead of the opinion.
If you work inside the Court, you know that the most concrete impact of the leak is to lock in this opinion essentially as is. Any edits at this point reveal jockeying between Justices, undermine the majority, and Court itself. Embarassing to the majority.
Liberals have lived for years trying to eke out a sentence here or there in SCOTUS opinions to make these conservative decisions less terrible. Why leak something and undermine that whole strategy?
Far and away most likely impact of the leaked draft is that it locks in 5 votes for this opinion, essentially without edits. Who would want that? So: This is about as extreme an opinion as you can have overturning Roe.
It talks about fetuses being people as a matter of ancient law (teeing up idea that fetuses are constitutionally PROTECTED – no abortion anywhere as matter of conlaw.) And its arguments undermine all of SCOTUS’s gay rights and contraception decisions.
Back to timing. Draft majorities circulate first, and then concurrences and dissents. So this is about the right timing for concurrences to come out. I think best bet is that Chief Justice Roberts circulated one recently, adopting a more moderate position.
Maybe Roberts says abortions ok in some time frame, preserving exceptions for the life of the woman, etc. And Kavanaugh is tempted by it – maybe not enough to vote for it, but enough to demand some changes to the Alito opinion.
Now let’s talk psychology of SCt clerks. The kinds of liberal students who end up at the Court are not an activist bunch. They are enormously risk averse and rule-abiding. Hard to see how one of them blows their career out of the water in this way (for what benefit?).
Leaking is much more of the style of conservatives right now. Think about what Justice Thomas is doing as a model for a clerk here – making a mockery of the Court’s recusal rules re. his wife’s role in the Jan 6 coup attempts.
Conservatives have shown that they are willing to break the public trust in the Court to get their way.
If you want the liberal view, read Justice Breyer’s recent book – LITERALLY CALLED “the peril of politics.”
https://www.hup.harvard.edu/catalog.php?isbn=9780674269361
Conservatives also know that the leak will be blamed on the left, distracting from how devastating the reversal of Roe will be to the credibility of the Court. The career consequences of someone found out are far smaller on right than left, too, I’d wager.
This is in NO WAY the most important story here. Alito’s opinion is horrific, and we have failed the young people of this country yet again. It’s a devastating moment. Much more to say about that, soon.
But I’m with @steve_vladeck and @joeyfishkin about what likely happened here. (Though I think done by a clerk, not a Justice). Occam’s razor. It just makes sense.
Originally tweeted by Amy Kapczynski (@akapczynski) on May 3, 2022.
As I wrote last night, I don’t really care about the leak. The decision was coming down in June anyway and even if some of the rough edges were sanded off of it, it’s obvious that Roe is a goner and this country is devolving into a primitive state ever faster. But when you think about it, this draft had to have been leaked by someone who wanted it to have an impact on the decision (leaking it a month early would hardly be important for electoral purposes) and the most logical reason would be to try to lock in this Alito opinion, not to have them rework it in a month.
No, it’s likely some radical wingnut working in the Court (or a radical Justice) decided that it was important to get Alito’s draft out there to stop whatever compromises might have been made. I don’t know if we’ll ever find out what happened and frankly I’m not super interested. The decision is what’s important and it’s a nightmare for this country. We’re heading back to the 50’s alright. The 1850s.