Mark Caputo at Axios looks at the tariff process in the White House. It’s not pretty:
Stop trying to predict and appraise President Trump’s tariffs policies based on economic theories or market realities. Tariffs are pure psychology for the president, fused into his brain like no other topic.
Why it matters: Trump’s tariff brain is unpredictable to the outside (and to market analysts) but wholly knowable to those who know how his mind works.
- “There’ll be trial and error. There’ll be pushing the envelope. There’ll be all of that Trumpian stuff,” said a top adviser involved in trade discussions.
Trump approaches tariffs, the remaking of the U.S. economy and the reshaping of global trade as a continuation of his presidential campaign.
- He ignored experts and assembled a team dedicated to executing his will and shrugging off the consequences of his unpredictability. He’s not changing now — rocky rollout and chaotic financial markets be damned.
- “Donald Trump works at his own tempo, and he doesn’t change the subject until he’s sure he’s clubbed people into seeing it as he does,” the adviser said.
Between the lines: In Trump’s first term, free traders such as then-National Economic Council Director Gary Cohn controlled Trump’s impulses to impose tariffs the way he has now. Trump’s current NEC chief, Kevin Hassett, is pro-tariff.
- So is the rest of the economic team: Vice President Vance, Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick, Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent, White House trade adviser Peter Navarro, Council of Economic Advisers chair Steven Miran, and U.S. Trade Representative Jamieson Greer.
The intrigue: Trump keeps such a huge team of advisers because he invariably solicits conflicting opinions. He often suffers from analysis paralysis and can be particularly influenced by whomever he talks with last.
- Trump also can be unclear on specifics, resulting in contradictory messages from his advisers, each of whom serves as a TV avatar of his tariff brain. Bessent and Lutnick have been criticized for giving mixed messages.
- “We saw it in business with Trump,” one adviser said. “He would have these meetings and everyone would agree, and then we would just pray that when he left the office and got on the elevator that the doorman wouldn’t share his opinion, because there would be a 50/50 chance [Trump] would suddenly side with the doorman.”
- “There are too many people in his ear,” the adviser said. “You didn’t see this with other presidents. Nixon didn’t act as the maître d’ of his own supper club, where every millionaire and billionaire who could get to him at dinner could chime in and affect policy.”
On political issues, Trump is often more directionally consistent than his critics give him credit for. He’s liable to switch up on policy specifics. But the direction is clear: tariffs. The specifics: wide-ranging.
- “It’s about several things,” his adviser said. “It’s about isolating China. It’s about making money for the United States Treasury. It’s about settling what Donald Trump believes is a score where, as he says, stupid people allowed countries to take advantage of us and ripping us off.”
Apparently the past 40 years have been pure hell for all the billionaires in Trump’s cabinet:
Animating Trump and his team is the belief, his adviser said, that “in its very most basic form, the patient, which is the United States economy, has been very sick. It’s been sick for 40 years, and nobody would say so.”
I actually think this is giving Trump too much credit. There is no rhyme or reason for Trump’s economic policies. It’s just that he can’t admit that he’s ever been wrong about anything and is incredibly stupid. He got obsessed with tariffs back in the 1980s and just kept repeating it like it was a brilliant insight.