Lawlessness, incompetence, and cruelty

Donald Trump’s Department of Homeland Security (DHS) Secretary Krisiti Noem made herself a laughingstock on Tuesday in an appearance before the Senate Appropriations Committee. When Sen. Maggie Hassan (D) of New Hampshire asked Noem to define habeas corpus, Noem immediately went off the rails. Noem made it clear that she’s cosplaying as law enforcement even when she’s not wearing body armor and pointing a gun in an officer’s face.
Behold:
Noem was before the committee to account for how she’s doing her job and managing her budget. Democrats were withering in their criticism.
Noem’s Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents have been snatching people off the street and deporting them without allowing them their due process rights since she took office in January. Her department repeatedly has defied court orders that it comply with constitutional norms. The administration took that battle to the U.S. Supreme Court last week.
As podcaster Brian Tyler Cohen put it, Noem “is either ignorant about the Constitution or willfully choosing to ignore its plain text out of convenience.” But that’s what Donald Trump wants from his employees, “to debase yourself on behalf of the god-king,” Cohen continues. “If you’re not throwing yourself in the line of fire, if you’re not throwing yourself on the grenade for an autocratic ruler, then you’re not fulfilling the principal function of your job.”
Vice chair Patty Murray (D) of Washington state questioned Noem about her department’s handling of deportations and the funding freeze or cancellation of over $100 billion in FEMA disaster relief and grants approved by Congress:
“As Senator Murphy mentioned in his opening statement, Secretary Noem, under your leadership, we have seen you ignore our appropriations laws, our constitution, common sense, and even basic humanity.
“Like a lot of Americans, I really have been horrified by the lawlessness, incompetence, and cruelty we have all witnessed.
Regarding that disaster assistance, Murray said, “We are talking about everything from disaster relief to grants that keep people safe. But when my staff has requested information on the status of this unacceptable hold-up, the Department failed to provide any acceptable justification. This illegal freeze—and it is illegal—is taking a real toll on communities who are waiting on the investments that Congress has delivered.”
Noem filibustered.
In the wake of the direct hit St. Louis took from an EF3 tornado on Friday, Missouri’s Sen. Josh Hawley (R) pleaded with Noem for assistance from the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) under her department’s umbrella. She was more responsive to the GOP senator from a red state.
Noem promised to expedite assistance to Missouri and advocated for reforming FEMA (WDSU):
But her assurances come amid ongoing turmoil at the Federal Emergency Management Agency. The agency’s former acting administrator, Cameron Hamilton, was ousted after publicly opposing President Trump’s proposal to dismantle FEMA.
His replacement, acting Administrator David Richardson, is expected to unveil new policy guidelines which could include increased cost-sharing requirements for states and a policy shift toward FEMA only coordinating federal assistance “when deemed necessary.”
Critics warn the moves could undercut disaster relief at a time when more Americans are relying on federal assistance in the wake of severe weather events.
Already, the Trump administration has denied FEMA aid for a windstorm in Washington State, flooding in West Virginia and extending cleanup efforts tied to Hurricane Helene in North Carolina.
Helene’s aftermath
Speaking of that denial of aid to North Carolina for Helene cleanup, “Frontline” and NPR on Tuesday reviewed disaster assistance to communities like ours hit by climate change-supercharged storm effects:
In “Hurricane Helene’s Deadly Warning,” Laura Sullivan goes on the ground in North Carolina in the days after the 2024 storm and speaks with survivors who describe the devastation, fear and shock they experienced at seeing entire communities washed away. She revisits Houston, Texas, where thousands of homes remain in an area that already flooded during Harvey in 2017. Sullivan also returns to Staten Island, where, according to a former FEMA director, the billion dollar rebuilding process may not have been enough to prevent mass destruction should another Superstorm Sandy hit.
“The federal government spends more than $50 billion a year to help communities recover, including properties that have flooded repeatedly in what seems like an endless cycle of destruction and rebuilding,” says Sullivan. “Our new joint investigation examines the forces fueling this cycle, whether places that have rebuilt after devastating floods are any safer today, and how this process is now playing out in North Carolina.”
Weeks away from hurricane season, the Trump administration is cutting the legs out from under federal relief preparation and response in terms of funding and experienced personnel.
Lawlessness, incompetence, and cruelty are all the point. And every day Trump is making it.
Here in WNC, we’ve recently experienced plague, floods, fires, pestilence, hail, and even an earthquake. All that’s left is for Trump and three of his cabinet members to put in an appearance on horseback. Kristi Noem is sure to make Team Apocalypse.
* * * * *
Have you fought dictatorship today?
No Kings Day, June 14th
The Resistance Lab
Choose Democracy
Indivisible: A Guide to Democracy on the Brink
You Have Power
Chop Wood, Carry Water
Thirty lonely but beautiful actions
Attending a Protest Surveillance Self-Defense










