I wrote earlier today about the fact that many of the “tree of liberty” types are suddenly defending the government saying people who carry guns should expect to be shot by police but as Garrett Graff points out in this piece, it’s not the only instance of the freedom-loving right suddenly feeling the love for Big Government jack-booted thugs:
The criticism was in line with another major recent rhetorical twist as the Trump administration’s heavy-handed crackdown on immigration has spread nationwide: The MAGA right, which just six years ago criticized Covid vaccine mandates as the first step toward concentration camps, have quickly fallen in line behind ICE and CBP raids — agreeing that Americans should just carry their citizenship documents everywhere and obey law enforcement demands instantly.
In the wake of the shooting of Renee Nicole Good by an ICE officer, President Trump — who began his presidency by pardoning the 1,600 protestors convicted of federal crimes for their role in January 6th, including people convicted of assaulting police officers, and whose movement has made a martyr of Ashli Babbitt, who was killed by Capitol Police after ignoring orders from officers to stop forcing her way toward the US House chamber — brushed off the shooting, saying, “That woman was very, very disrespectful to law enforcement.”
Anyone who didn’t obey law enforcement, like Good, deserved the ICE death penalty, the argument appeared to be.
In a similar vein in recent days, Kristi Noem — who as South Dakota governor rose to national prominence during the COVID-19 pandemic in 2020 over her refusal to issue a statewide mandate to wear face masks — now in her role as DHS secretary proclaimed that Americans should just get used to carrying citizenship documents and showing them as necessary.
At first the series of rhetorical flip-flops may seem nonsensical — as if the world is upside down — but all of them are consistent with decades of evolution of white nationalist ideology and the far-right movement, which isn’t against tyranny per se, just tyranny by the “wrong people”: Democrats, women, or minorities.
In fact, what many have long short-handed as “anti-government extremists,” from Ruby Ridge and Waco to the Bundy showdowns of the Obama years to the crowd that stormed the Michigan State Capitol amid the Covid lockdown, are not actually “anti-government” or even “anti-tyranny.” They are instead simply “extremists,” driven by secondary motives — often threads of white Christian nationalism or white supremacy that date their vision back to texts like the 1978 bible-of-the-fringe Turner Diaries.
And now, looking across the American landscape, those far-right white nationalists feel comfortable flipping their rhetoric because they recognize the Trump administration is doing their business for them. The government is their kind of extremist now.
He notes a very interesting phenomenon:
Terrorism scholars noted with surprise how extralegal right-wing violence plunged in 2025; according to a September study by the Center for Strategic and International Studies, through July 4, “2025 marks the first time in more than 30 years that left-wing terrorist attacks outnumber those from the violent far right.”
Similarly, long-standing right-wing militia groups have gone quiet or dormant. An August article by The Atlantic asked, “Where have the Proud Boys Gone?” and concluded that there was little need anymore for the militia whose leadership was convicted of “seditious conspiracy” for their role in the January 6th insurrection at the Capitol. “The group’s ideals are being pursued—but by ICE and the government itself,” the Atlantic wrote.
Who needs militias and domestic terrorism when the government is doing their work for them?
You could see this in the Reagan worship and the reaction after 9/11. Trump just pushed the envelope to the level of the Proud Boys because he comes out of that toxic petrie dish himself. Today it defines the Republican Party.