For Republicans, for Democrats, for the republic
In yesterday’s Starting The Steal, we discussed the Republican legal challenge to losing the North Carolina state Supreme Court race in November. But today consider the national implications. Even a Republican gets it (sort of).
Andrew Dunn of Longleaf Politics believes it a bad idea for Court of Appeals Judge Jefferson Griffin to fight his loss all the way to the GOP-controlled state Supreme Court he’s desperate to join. Republicans want to throw out 60,000 votes “on technicalities in voter registration.” Read more about that here and here.
“I’m not sure who’s leading the push here — but it needs to end now,” writes Dunn:
If the Supreme Court sides with Griffin, the fallout will be immediate and brutal. This isn’t just bad optics; it’s potentially a credibility-shattering disaster for the court, the party, and conservatism in North Carolina. Overnight, this becomes a national story about Republicans “stealing” a Supreme Court seat. The allegation would be impossible to defend against.
And it wouldn’t end there. A ruling for Griffin would hand Democrats the perfect weapon: a story that’s simple, emotional, and devastating. It’s not hard to imagine Republicans losing judicial races — and even key legislative seats in 2026 — because of the stink this case would leave behind.
If Griffin loses the appeal, the damage is only slightly contained. The party will have spent months locked in a fight that divides its base and gives Democrats fresh ammunition for future campaigns. This appeal makes future judicial races even harder.
Dunn is neglecting the national fallout.
REDMAP, the 2010 GOP effort to win control over 2011 redistricting/gerrymandering, was midwifed by North Carolina’s Thomas B. Hoffeler, as was the Republican effort to rig the 2020 census. After Roy Cooper ousted N.C. Republican Gov. Pat McCrory in 2016, Republicans called a lame-duck session to strip Cooper of many powers of his office before inauguration. The tactic spread to Wisconsin in 2018 when Democrat Tony Evers defeated Republican Gov. Scott Walker. (North Carolina wrote the playbook Wisconsin and Michigan are using to undermine democracy.) N.C. Republicans just succeeded again in stripping Democratic governor-elect Josh Stein of some of his appointment powers.
David Pepper calls the states “Laboratories of Autocracy.” North Carolina is chief among them. If North Carolina Republicans succeed in cancelling 60,000 voters’ ballots (including Republican voters; they’re not safe when stealing an election is in play) because their voter file lacks a driver’s license number or the last four digits of their Social Security number, that challenge tactic too will spread to other states. Yours very likely.
Update: Added Common Cause post from Bluesky
Thank you sharing this Sanctuary of Sanity with us each day.
Happy Hollandaise!