Meme Vaccine
Before the meme spreads, let’s try to knock it out with a good dose of pre-emptive truth.
George Tenet is not responsible for the fact that the administration’s claims that Saddam’s WMD and terrorist ties were bogus — the president, vice president and secretary of defense are. George Tenet is personally responsible to the extent that he was a good little soldier instead of resigning as he should have when he realized that they were just making shit up. That particular form of integrity seems to be as out of fashion as firing people for incompetence.
People note that according to Bob Woodward, Tenet responded to the “skeptical” president that the WMD was a “slam dunk,” which is taken as some sort of proof that Bush was hoodwinked against his own better instincts. This is nonsense. As Bob Sommerby has pointed out, this conversation took place in December of 2002, three months after Bush had begun riding his white charger all over the country proclaiming that we had to “disarm Saddam Hussein.” He rode that horse to a narrow midterm victory for the GOP, flanked by flags and teary eyed country troubadours to great effect. If he wasn’t sure of the evidence, he certainly didn’t show any sign of it when he was calling the Democrats a bunch of cowards who didn’t care about national security and warning them that they would be punished by the voters if they didn’t vote for war.
If anything, Bush should be heavily criticized for not asking that question before he embarked on his crusade instead of waiting until we were poised to invade. That Tenet erroneously validated Bush’s obvious wish to believe is no testament to his courage. But, if he hadn’t said “it’s a slam dunk” it’s hardly believable that Bush would have pulled the country back from war at that point. The marketing roll out had long since begun and there was no going back.
However, let’s be clear. The CIA never claimed that Saddam had nukes or terrorist ties. What they believed was that Saddam had a cache of chemical and bio weapons. Indeed, Tenet testified before congress that the most likely scenario in which Saddam might use those weapons was an American invasion of Iraq. (That was a very confusing addition to the debate and one which was simply swept under the carpet.)
So, I’m not defending the unbelievably lousy intelligence on Iraq. Clearly, we have some very serious problems. Before Gulf War I we were apparently clueless that Saddam had been quite far along with a nuclear program. So, in response we apparently assumed that he had super human talents and overestimated his abilities from that point forward. There is little doubt that the CIA is less James Bond than Inspector Clouseau. (It’s a shame that Bush and company felt it necessary to be transparent about this aspect of our government at a time when terrorists are trying to kill us. But, that’s our lil’ Crusader Codpiece — pretty much doing the exact opposite of the smart thing every single time.)
Having said that, the neocons have always been even more wrong than the CIA. For a quarter century they have have been screaming that the sky is falling, from the grossly incorrect Team B in the 1970’s to the Office of Special Plans fantasy camp in the pentagon post 9/11. They have consistently overestimated the military strength and super-villainous intentions of our enemies to the point at which one could conclude that we should invade and occupy the entire world, just to be on the safe side. In fact, that is the underlying premise of “Rebuilding America’s Defenses.”
The war was sold on the nuclear and terrorist threat and the grand delusion of a reverse domino theory in the region. All of that was bullshit. George Tenet is guilty of attaching his personal prestige as the director of the CIA to that disinformation program. But, let’s not let the neocons get away with pinning the entire Iraq cock-up on him. This was a neocon program from day one.
For more: